Graphite vs Steel Shaft
Is your performance in the golf course is being compromised and not improving despite practicing? If the answer to this question is ‘Yes,’ then you might consider the material with which your golf shaft is made up of.
The material of the shaft might be the one reason due to which your performance at the golf course is not improving. Choosing the right golf club shaft makes a considerable difference in the performance. Let’s learn about Graphite vs Steel Shaft.
The main difference between the graphite shaft and the steel shaft is the material that they are made up of. As the name suggests, the graphite shaft is made up of the graphite, while the steel shaft is made up of the steel.
Steel Vs Graphite Shaft: Pivotal Factors to Decide
The pivotal factors to look when deciding about the material of the shaft are listed and discussed below.
- Skill Level / Experience
- Ability to Work the Ball
- Type of Wedges, Putter and Irons
Skill Level / Experience
The skill level or the experience matters a lot when deciding about the shafts, graphite, or steel. In case a golf player is a novice player and requires further training, the choice for the player is graphite shaft.
It is mainly because the graphite shafts are lighter in weight and offer better swing speed. On the other hand, the steel shaft offers better stability due to its weight and offers lower swing speed to the players suffer due to higher swing speed.
In short, for ‘the shafts, graphite, or steel, the graphite works better for novice, recreational, and handicappers while the steel ones work better for skilled and experienced players.
The feel of steel shafts is a bit tougher as they are heavier, rigid, and have lesser flexibility. On the other hand, the feel offered by the graphite shafts is better as they are lighter in weight, less rigid, and offer more flexibility than the steel shaft.
Therefore, given the feel factor, the graphite shaft is preferred by the women golf players more than the men golf players.
Ability to Work with the Ball
The ability to work with the ball resonates with the skill level and experience of golf players. But there is a difference. A golf player with experience and high skills may not have polished his or her ability to work with the ball. Or on the other hand, a player having the ability to work with the ball may not be overall skilled and experienced in golf.
Therefore, the ability to work with the ball has a different connotation when it comes to playing golf. In terms of golf clubs, steel shaft is a preferred choice for the players who have more ability to work with the ball than the players who are still learning to do it.
Types of Wedges, Putters, and Irons
The type of shaft matters a lot when it comes to types of wedges, putters, and irons. For having a great feel with wedges, the steel shaft offers a much better feel than the graphite ones. Unless one is looking for a cheap solution, with wedges, the steel shafts are the right choice.
The shafts for the putters are the steel ones. It is because the flexibility offered by the graphite shaft is of no to little use when it comes to putters.
Therefore, mainly because of the feel offered by the steel shafts, the putters with steel are preferred. The graphite shafts in Irons are preferred over the Irons shafts in Irons. It is mainly because the graphite shafts in Irons offer better swing speed.
Steel Vs. Graphite Shafts: Which is Better?
It is probably is a million-dollar question. As a golf player, which shaft is better for me, steels ones or the graphite ones?. It is a tricky question with a lot of right answers.
It is the reason, instead of answering the question right away, we will help equip you with the right information to decide yourself about the shafts type, which is just right for you.
Pros and Cons of Steel Shafts
In the following section, the pros and cons of steel shafts are discussed.
Pros of Steel Shafts
What does an expert doctor do to know about the health of a patient? S/he takes the pulse of the patient!. Similarly, an expert golf player gets to know about the health of his/her shot by taking the pulse of his/her shot.
The pulse of the shot is taken by the vibration the player receives through the shaft during as the ball is hit.
A skilled player gets to know about the quality of the hit, the right or wrong shot, by the very feel of impact and swing. It travels in the form of vibrations to the player through the steel shaft.
The steel shafts are less expensive than their counterpart graphite shafts. Thus, they become a natural choice, who are recreational players, and who might want to see if golf is what they want to choose as a sport.
The steel shafts are heavier in weight than their counterpart graphite shafts. It may seem to be a negative side of the steel shafts, but this weight offers an advantage to the high swing speed players.
Due to the weight, their high speed is managed a little, which helps such players to play a better shot.
Cons of Steel Shafts
The steel shafts are heavier than the graphite shafts. The heavier steel shaft may be found by novice, recreational, and women golf players as a put-off. Therefore, they prefer the lightweight golf shafts, the graphite shafts over steel shafts.
Further, the weight reduces the swing speed, which puts the senior golf players and handicappers at a disadvantage than their counterparts.
While the experienced golf players find it very interesting and a way of knowing the quality of their shots, the vibrations are found as something not welcoming by the novice, recreational, and women golfers.
Pros and Cons of Graphite Shafts
In the following section, the pros and cons of graphite shafts are discussed.
Pros of Graphite Shafts
The graphite shafts are lighter in weight than their counterpart steel shafts. In terms of graphite vs steel shafts, this gives the graphite shafts an edge over the steel shafts. It is sometimes a decisive point for the novice, recreational, and women golfers as they give preference to graphite shafts over the steel shafts.
The lightweight also helps in having a better swing speed, and therefore the longer distance is covered by the ball. It is an essential variable for handicappers and senior golf players. The lightweight of the graphite shaft allows them to have high swing speed, through which they achieve a longer distance.
Cons of Graphite Shafts
In graphite vs. steel shafts, the graphite shafts are more flexible than the steel shafts. Due to this reason, sometimes the accuracy, swing, and distance offered by golf clubs are often compromised.
The graphite shafts are a little expensive than their counterpart steel shafts. Therefore, the new golf enthusiasts may find this as a little heavy on their pockets for a sport that is at the exploration stage for them.
Final Verdict: Graphite Vs Steel Shaft
Steel or graphite shafts? Is the one better than the other? We have provided you with the necessary information required to decide in deciding steel or graphite shafts.
The choice to pick steel or graphite shafts boils down to your’ 1) personal choice, 2) handicap, 3) experience & skill level, 4) age, and even 5) gender. Every golf player has a different combination of each of the variables, as mentioned above.
Therefore, as a golf player, there is no ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ answer. It would be best if you chose between the steel or graphite shafts depending upon how it feels to you and through which you get the best results.
The type of shaft does matter, and choosing the right shaft for your golf club can make a decisive improvement in your game.
All the tournament players have enjoyed playing golf with steel and graphite both. Accordingly, it would be best if you tried both the steel and graphite shaft before you finalize your pick.